Halfway along the brick passage that links Throckmorton and Sunnyside avenues, the walls inside the restaurant at 17 Throckmorton are back to their original color. A previous owner had whitewashed that brick, and the new owner had it sandblasted. The person who ordered that work is Edwin Sandoval, a Novato resident who has spent 35 years in construction. He is also the owner of Lima Nikkei, the Japanese-Peruvian restaurant that now fills El Paseo's dining rooms, as the Marin Independent Journal reported in late October.
El Paseo's newest tenant is a builder, and his renovation took the rooms back toward the materials their creators went looking for after World War II.
A builder's renovation of a builder's passage
Sandoval owns Atlas Construction, and he oversaw the renovation himself. Besides the brick, the dark-stained wood floors were refinished in a lighter shade and all 56 light fixtures were replaced. The main dining room pairs the bare brick with pale wood furniture and curved upholstered banquettes. Vertical wood slats give the bar a Japanese look. The back room keeps more of the building's original character, with colored glass windows and exposed rafters. All told, the restaurant seats about 125 guests.
That brick has a story, and it starts with one Mill Valley resident. According to the Mapping Mill Valley History project, which draws on the Library's Lucretia Little History Room, Edna and Henry Foster bought the run-down Holtum Building at 15 Throckmorton and the lot behind it on Sunnyside in 1935. Edna, who called the old building an "old eyesore," hired local architect Augustus "Gus" Costigan. Together they planned a cluster of buildings, courts and gardens with a passage running from street to street. She named it El Paseo, from the Spanish word for "scenic path."
Construction began in 1940, and two shops and some studio apartments were done by the time the war arrived. Then the war stopped the project. Costigan served with the Army Combat Engineers in Africa and Italy. When he came home, he and Foster went hunting for materials that looked old. Per the same history, they found adobe bricks from Mexico, beams from a building being torn down at Fort Cronkite, railroad ties and spikes, handmade tiles and wrought-iron fixtures. Costigan hand-carved beams and balustrades and set champagne bottles into the walls to mimic stained glass. The complex was finished in 1948, and a two-day "Fiestaval" on May 15 and 16 marked the opening.
Mill Valley's Historic Resources Inventory lists "17 Throckmorton Avenue (El Paseo Complex)," built in 1948, as eligible under National and California Register criterion C/3. The city describes the inventory as a record of resources found eligible for those registers. It is not a list of local landmarks, and the complex has no Historic Overlay zoning. The inventory also treats the complex of linked buildings and lanes as separate from the restaurant that has rented it for so long.
Dinner in the same rooms since 1947
The restaurant is older than the finished complex. Mapping Mill Valley History dates it to 1947, a year before construction wrapped up, and it has had a long series of owners since.
| Years | Operators | Kitchen |
|---|---|---|
| 1947 to 1957 | Mildred Snell and Amy Hanson | The first owners |
| 1957 to 1972 | Mary Harkins | Continental |
| 1972 to 2005 | Mark Bottmeyer and Gunter Kollner | French, with a wine bar added 13 years in |
| 2006 to 2009 | Chef Keiko Takahashi and sommelier Seigo Takei | French, awarded a Michelin star |
| 2011 to 2018 | Tyler Florence and Sammy Hagar, then Hagar alone | Steakhouse, later Spanish |
| 2019 to 2025 | Ki Yong Choi | Paseo: A California Bistro |
| 2026 | Edwin Sandoval | Lima Nikkei, Japanese-Peruvian |
Takahashi and Takei stepped aside on October 7, 2009. That ended more than 52 years of French and Continental cooking in the space. Next came a long renovation. According to a 2011 Marin Independent Journal review, El Paseo House of Chops opened on March 19, 2011, with Florence running an American steakhouse menu alongside chef Preston Clark. The San Francisco Chronicle reported that the partners split in 2016. Hagar moved the menu toward Spanish food and closed the restaurant in 2018, saying the daily work had become "far too time consuming." In 2019 he sold the business to longtime Mill Valley resident Ki Yong Choi.
Choi's restaurant was Paseo: A California Bistro, with a seasonal menu sourced within 100 miles. Its general manager, Kevin Pacotti, said the plan was to keep the historic location's style as much as possible. The Mill Valley Chamber of Commerce announced that the bistro would close on December 20, 2025, and told readers to stay tuned for what came next.
The space's 52-year French era ended with a Japanese chef cooking French food. Lima Nikkei puts Japanese technique right on the menu, by way of Peru.
Ordering at Lima Nikkei
Nikkei cooking grew out of Japanese immigration to Peru that began more than a century ago. The menu here is built for sharing. Sandoval, who grew up in Lima and worked in his family's restaurants there in the 1970s, wrote it himself. He hired another Lima native, Wilmer Anaya, to run the kitchen. Anaya's résumé includes La Mar Cebichería Peruana in San Francisco.
The Independent Journal's October report described the opening menu in sections:
- Ceviches. There are six. Yellowfin tuna comes in ají amarillo leche de tigre with wasabi and shredded nori. Octopus comes with a black olive emulsion and chimichurri.
- Maki. Four rolls, including shrimp tempura with avocado and cucumber wrapped in fresh fish with cebichera sauce, and a yellowtail roll with cilantro, jalapeño and yuzu mayo.
- Bites and small plates. Bao de chicharrón with crispy pork belly and rocoto gochumayo, a Hokkaido scallop served in the shell with aged Parmesan foam, and roasted cauliflower with edamame hummus and huacatay, a Peruvian herb.
- Larger plates. Lomo saltado made with beef tenderloin, udon in a Peruvian chile coconut curry with salmon and shrimp, an Australian wagyu New York strip, and a center-cut filet mignon with yuca fries.
- Robata skewers. Chicken, beef tenderloin, wild salmon, Spanish octopus and mushrooms, served on miniature Japanese grills in the style of Peruvian anticuchos.
The seafood comes from Four Star Seafood & Provisions in San Francisco and the meat from Chicago's Allen Brothers. Bartender Lee Bustamante worked with Sandoval on the cocktails. The Paseo Sour mixes pisco, matcha, shochu, yuzu and black sesame syrup. The Miso Elixir arrives with a sweet potato anticucho on the side. The Amazonian Geisha pairs Haku vodka with camu camu and ume plum liqueur.
It's a family operation. Sandoval has said he reopened as a restaurateur to give his grandchildren an opportunity. His grandson Lukas, a business student at College of Marin, manages the restaurant, and his granddaughter Claudia handles the books and marketing.
Lima Nikkei serves dinner from 4 to 9 p.m. Sunday through Thursday and from 4 to 10 p.m. Friday and Saturday. You can book through the restaurant's website.
Making an evening of it downtown
El Paseo is a lane you walk through, so plan to enter from one street and leave by the other. The Mill Valley Public Library holds Edna Foster's oral history interview, in which she tells the story of building the complex in her own words.
Ten days after Thanksgiving, downtown gets busier. The Chamber's Winterfest starts at 1 p.m. on Sunday, December 6, at Depot Plaza and Lytton Square, with hands-on children's activities, crafts, performances and a tree lighting. The Chamber has also listed performances by Happy Feet and Marin Conservatory of Dance, plus a new holiday lighting installation that starts at Depot Plaza. Lima Nikkei opens at 4 p.m., late in the Winterfest afternoon. For more about downtown and the streets around it, see our Mill Valley neighborhood guide. For another look at how old Mill Valley traditions keep going, read our piece on the Fall Arts Festival's start as a sidewalk show.
Many Mill Valley homes have history in their walls too, from original brick to beams with a past of their own. If you own one and wonder what it would take to show those features off, or what they mean when it's time to sell, the Kristie Martinelli Team is glad to walk through it with you. Work With Us.